Quite the little show they’ve got going here. What I find most interesting about this show is how they have made (or tried to make?) such ridiculous, unbelievable characters human. Perhaps it’s just because I’ve never really worked in an office environment like this, but people aren’t really that crazy, are they? I think they kind of are, but sometimes it goes over the top. So how do they make up for that? By giving these characters strong pieces of humanity. Then, we forgive them for their insanity, and care for them when that’s called for. As absolutely ridiculous as Dwight is, you kind of really feel for him when Angela is legit engaged to Andy. You know you shouldn’t, but the show does a really fantastic job of making you care. Without even realizing it, you want things to turn out well for these people, even the ones you don’t like. And that’s really the challenge of the modern day sitcom. Make the audience care about your crazy characters enough that the audience will forgive these ridiculous people all of their insanity while still being entertained.
The show also does a really amazing job of developing all of their characters. With the exception of maybe Creed, I really enjoy the comedic presence of every single character on this show, which is rare and impressive. Without ever dedicating a full episode to Stanley or Kevin, I really love these characters and what they bring to the tone and presence of the show. But moving on to the seasons I watched recently…
Season Three seems to be the high point of the show. The drama and tension were high, with Jim and Pam still pining after each other. Even with episodes that had nothing to do with them, you could feel the tension in the office place of their smoldering desire. So not only were the jokes hitting hard, but it carried real resonance with this added level of drama that felt really urgent.
Season Four dropped the ball quite a bit in my opinion. You totally lost the Jim and Pam tension, and the show really took a while to recover from that. Things didn’t feel as important once they were together, and I guess there had just been so much build up that you kind of want to expect something more, something you know you will never get. Also, the season was cut short because of the writers strike, and for some reason they had all of these two part episodes that just didn’t work. I never realized this, but there is a reason sitcoms are only a half of an hour (or 22 minutes) long. It’s because that is the amount of time that perfectly allows for a little bit of story and drama without needing anything too complicated. The Office can pull off these extended episodes every once in a while for major events, but not on a consistent basis, which is what it tried here in Season 4. Things got confusing, convoluted, unnecessary, and meandering real fast, and the episodes lost the zip that makes them special.
Season 5 attempted to get back to form, and had occasional glimpses of the power of this show, but spent a lot of the time lost in the murk of reaching for real plot arcs. This show is at its best when you just have a “normal” day at the office and let the characters go through their hi-jinks. Manufactured dramatic plot arcs, such as Michael quitting and taking Pam and Ryan with him, feel forced and unnecessary. They also lose a lot of the humor in trying to tell stories. And at the end of the day, you feel a little used when things end up back to exactly where they started, which is what you expected and knew would happen all along.
But people are right, this is easily one of the best comedies that has been on television in a long time. The humor is stronger than 30 Rock, and the characters definitely have more heart. While not as funny or layered as Arrested Development, it clearly has the wider commercial appeal that AD was lacking, and that has got to count for something.
I watched the British The Office first, and I still have to say that I like that better, especially considering the nice way that show was just a little package. They never milked it or dragged it out, which allowed them to not take their characters as seriously. You never needed to give the Dwight character a bit heart, because you didn’t need people to care long enough for it to matter. And when it ran its course it was over. I will definitely watch Season Six of The Office when it comes out on Netflix streaming (and I am super excited for the wedding!), but I also know there are going to be quite a few slow episodes.